I will miss
my father.
Two things
I will miss are his handshake and his smile, and I suspect that others will
remember them as well. Both were
engaging. His handshake was firm and
engaging; his smile was friendly and engaging, with a hint of mischief. Never a confident speaker, Dad communicated
much with his handshake and smile, and both were genuine - they continued
through the very last days of his life, when because of weakness and delirium,
deceit would not have been possible.
Dad smiled
at us - we who loved him - to the very end.
I think his last purposeful communication with me was a smile. I was sitting by his bedside on the Friday evening
before his death, singing softly to him, and he smiled at me. It was no longer his smile of old, but the
twinkling light was still in his eyes. I
know those who were there remember his big, expansive smile when we finally had
his breathing tube removed on Thursday before moving him to palliative
care. And nurses commented that they
don’t usually see smiles like his in the ICU or in the final days of an illness
like his.
In the
hospital, doctors and nurses ask patients to squeeze their fingers as a
neurological test and sign of alertness.
Whenever he could, Dad would give them a mighty firm squeeze. Even when his strength had ebbed such that he
could not even adjust his position in bed, his grip remained firm, and sometimes doctors had trouble extricating
their fingers from his hand. I think he
was showing off a little. When we moved
him to palliative care, my mother, my sister and I took turns holding both of
his hands. He held ours in return,
keeping that communion with us and keeping hold of Mom’s hand when she would
try to get up for a moment.
In his last
hours when he could no longer hold our hands, we continued to hold his. And when he died on Sunday morning, his hand
was in mine. That was a comfort to me
and I hope it was a comfort to him as well.
I will also
miss Dad’s voice and some of the little things he would say. He had a rich and pleasant speaking voice,
even though he was not confident as a speaker.
He also had a nice singing voice.
I still remember how he sounded when I was little and from my bedroom at
night I would hear him singing Danny Boy at the piano. But I don’t remember him playing or singing
at all in later years.
Whenever I
was staying at the house in my adult years, we had a nightly ritual. When he and Mom were coming upstairs for bed
he would call up to me, asking “Are you coming down?” He wanted to know whether or not he should
leave a light on for me. I would answer
“yes” and he would reply, “Okay!” I will
forever remember his Okay. In his last year, after his stroke, his voice
was less vibrant than it had been, but every now and then his okay would come
through as strong and rich as it ever did, and he sounded again like my dad of
old. By then time we were leaving a
light on downstairs regardless – for safety at night – but our ritual remained.
One friend
of mine from my youth remembers the distinctive way Dad would answer the
telephone. And perhaps others who used
to call the house remember his “mmmm yello!”
I will miss
other rituals as well. When I see beers
in the refrigerator it is a stabbing reminder that I will never share another
beer with my dad. The last beer we drank
together was the English pub draft, Boddington’s. It was his first time tasting Boddington’s
and he said he loved it. In his last
year, I took to buying beers that I thought he would like to try: Warsteiner
Verum and Dunkel, pub draft and regular stout Guinness, and other hearty
varieties. He said of all of them that
he thought they might be his favorite. I
regret not taking more time to drink beers with him in his last months. Often he would catch me about to leave the
house, or else it would be in the evening when Mom didn’t like him drinking
beer because of his incontinence problems, stemming from treatments for
prostate cancer. But now, with no
opportunity to share that ritual again, I regret not taking every opportunity I
had.
Beer
drinking was probably our oldest ritual together, stretching back to when I was
a small boy and we were living on Coventry Road in Shaker Heights. Back then he would often drink Genesee beer,
a lower-priced brew made in upstate New York. He would pour the beer from can
to mug and also pour a small amount for me into a Dixie cup. The cup was almost entirely foam, which was
fine by me since the foam was what I was interested in. I loved the taste and the texture and it felt
like a special treat (and a grown-up thing) to share with my dad. To this day, I love the taste of Genesee.
One of
these times occurred when I was very young and we were walking in what I
remember as Shenandoah National Park. It
might have actually been a place in Ohio, since I would have been very young
when we lived near Shenandoah to have formed such a clear memory. But wherever or whenever it was, we passed a
small group of what were - to my young mind - hippies. They asked my dad if he wanted a beer, and of
course he said yes. I remember looking
back and seeing him accept and begin to drink a can from one of the young men.
The other
memorable occasion occurred in Boston the night after Dad ran the Boston
marathon. That night we went to the No
Name seafood restaurant, and I remember it to be loud and crowded, and that
people from another table bought beer for Dad.
Perhaps he looked like he had probably just run the marathon – he
certainly had the build of a runner. Or
maybe, as we used to say about him, he just looked like someone who needed a
beer.
Appreciating
nature and running are two family traditions that have firmly taken root in
me. When I was young, as a family we
spent a good amount of time visiting nature by camping and hiking. When we lived in the DC area, we would go to
Shenandoah National Park, with its beautiful Skyline Drive, and the Great
Smokey Mountains. In Ohio we would go to
places like Nelson Ledges and Virginia Kendall in what is now the Cuyahoga
Valley National Park. We also took
vacations every summer to my mother’s family farm in Northern Wisconsin. I loved walking and running through the corn
fields and pastures of those farm acres, often with my Uncle Jim’s dog. Sometimes we would travel through Michigan
and camp with the car camper in the beautiful forests of northern Michigan and
the Upper Peninsula. And twice we went
to wilderness summits put on in the Rocky Mountains and the Appalachian
mountains.
Both my
parents were runners as far back as I remember, but especially my father. And me, too.
Like my sister, I began my running life by running with our parents, and
the tradition started so far back that I don’t remember I time when I didn’t
run. Running was something that my
parents began in the 1960s, when they were in their late 30s or early 40s. Dad became a pretty good age group runner in
local road races, taking many firsts in his age group. He had a few nemeses who were about his age,
including Jess Belle, the owner of the Bonnie Belle cosmetics company, who
sponsored a serious of road races for women only. Mom has a number of age group trophies – which
were bells of various sizes – from those races.
One
highlight of my youth running career was being youngest finisher at age eight
of the Cleveland Heart-a-thon half marathon.
Dad was instrumental in encouraging and helping me do that. My whole family had initially signed up, but
one by one they backed out due to injury or lack of training. But I still wanted to run, and to test my
readiness my dad took me out for a 12-mile run to be sure I was fit enough.
The
highlight of my dad’s running career was the Boston marathon, which he
qualified for and ran when he was 50 years old.
It was a big deal for us driving to Boston and watching him finish the
race. It was a cool and rainy day, and I
remember the Japanese drummers who set up an elaborate traditional drum
arrangement, and would play their drums whenever a Japanese runner approached
the finish. Dad’s official time was
about 3:05, but I have no doubt that he really ran under three hours that
day. Those were the days before chip
timing. Nowadays every runner has a
magnetic chip which records when they cross the start and finish lines and so
gives a true individualized time. But
Dad did not have that advantage and it surely took him at least 10 or even 20
minutes just to get to the starting line, so his true time was undoubtedly
under three hours, which is very respectable for a man in his fifties.
In 2010 we
took our last trip together as a family when we traveled again to Boston for
the marathon. My dad got to see his
daughter and a granddaughter run the marathon, and our family got to relive old
memories from our trip to Boston so many years ago.
As an
adult, I combined these two loves instilled by my father and mother – running
and nature when I began trail running while living in Northern California. My dad had a chance to see me run a 50-mile
race and also the 100-mile Western States 100.
I loved
hearing my dad tell how he got his start in running. He and my mom read Kenneth Cooper’s first book,
Aerobics. This book heralded the start of the running
and fitness boom that really took off in the early 1970s with the first New
York City Marathon and the world-class exploits of Frank Shorter in the Munich
Olympics, and his duels in New York and Boston with fellow legend Bill Rodgers. Kenneth Cooper recommended running in place
at home as one way to start an aerobic fitness program. I’m not sure why he promoted running in
place, but perhaps it was because it was unusual at that time to see regular
people out running on the streets. At
any rate, my father began running in place in the basement. One day after he had built up his endurance a
bit, he tried running on a track and - as
he would say - he never ran in the basement again. One day some time later, he and his running
partners tried running on the streets and sidewalks, and they never went back
to the track. (That’s not strictly true,
because in Cleveland during the winters we would run at the Jewish Community
Center’s indoor track. But in the
summers, Dad ran almost exclusively on the streets and sidewalks, and I often
ran with him.) I later extended this
evolution when I tried running on trails, and never wanted to run on roads
again.
Lately I
have begun teaching clinics about running form, and I use my father as an
example. His running style was very
distinctive, with a high knee lift, upright posture and rhythmic cadence
carried through his entire body.
Actually, his form was about perfect by current standards. I have wondered if his style came in part
from his months running in place before he ventured to the track. Running in place encourages good running
habits, and as a form drill is part of the curriculum of the clinics. I always talk about my father and use him as
an example for the benefits of running in place.
I think my
dad and I shared a passion a deeper than running and enjoying nature. We both have a passion for moving through and
exploring the land. When I run,
especially on trials, I take a great pleasure in moving through the land,
following its contours, experiencing the life and shape and nature of its
trees, grasses shrubs and animals; imbibing the rhythm and the feel of the land
which is underneath me and all around me.
I love the mountains, the hills, the forests and the prairies alike, and
delight in moving through them all. My
dad and I also shared a love for what he called “lonesome landscapes.” I may
have developed this through some sort of osmosis from my father, for I don’t
think we spent much time together in such places. He developed this affinity in the years that
he lived as a child in Oklahoma, western Kansas, and South Dakota. In later days, we both loved a video of the
stark landscapes of Iceland. And I have
loved both running and driving through the landscape in South Dakota, Wyoming,
Nebraska, Arizona, New Mexico and Texas.
Dad was a
great and prolific driver. He loved to
drive, and I inherited his passion and technique for long distance driving.
Like me, he enjoyed seeing new places, even if only driving through them, a
passion he perhaps developed taking long car trips with his mother when he was
a young man. Driving is another way to
move through the land, and dad loved it as do I. As a young man, he would drive from Western
Kansas into the Rocky Mountains in Colorado.
His sister remembers how he was always wanting to go to the mountains,
and she later realized that it was so he could drive on the curvy mountain
roadways. I believe he enjoyed the
technical aspects and also the joy of feeling the rhythms and the contours of
the land. In our drives to Florida and
South Carolina he would speak with admiration about the highways through the
Appalachian Mountains. And I feel the
same joy whether driving cross country or driving on the country roads in
Eastern Ohio.
Driving is
about the only thing that I do efficiently, and I learned this from Dad. Get on the road early and drive steadily,
taking few breaks. Dad would always
bypass as many rest stops as the gas tank would allow, often worrying my mother
as the gas gauge would drop down to (and sometimes past) zero. I do the same.
I can
remember when I was young, my father describing himself as a pessimist. He would tell us to be pessimistic and to
expect and plan for the worst. He said
that people of his generation learned this lesson during the Great Depression,
because they learned that nothing is certain.
He also said to hope for the best, but I seem to remember the emphasis
on the expect the worst side of the
equation.
But now I
know that Dad was not really a pessimist.
He was a dreamer. He titled
his memoir Reflections of a Life: A Memoir of Dreams and
Striving. Dreams were a central part
of Dad’s life from childhood right through the end of his life. He wrote in his memoir: “I think dreams can
be with us all of our days.” And while
dreams can “torment and tantalize” us, they also give our lives hope and
meaning. Poverty is insidious if it robs
a person of hope, but even wealth does not guarantee hope and meaning in one’s
life. It is dreams, be they large or
small, that make life worth living.
Dad chased
his biggest dreams through writing. At
my father’s funeral mass, the priest remarked that in the roughly twenty years
he was pastor at my parents’ church he could not remember ever hearing my
father speak. Dad did not consider
himself an effective speaker, especially public speaking. I suspect he was better than he believed
himself to be. He did have a nice
speaking voice, and his genuineness must surely have enhanced his lectures to
his business students at Cleveland State University. Be that as it may, it was not through
speaking, but through writing that he primarily and most powerfully engaged
with the world. And it was through
writing that he achieved his greatest successes.
Dad dreamed
of making a lasting impact on the world, and he strove to do this through his
writing. As a young professor of
business in 1972 he wrote his first book, an introductory marketing textbook
titled Marketing: Management and Social
Change. He tried to introduce a
strong sense of ethics, compassion, and what today would be called
sustainability into business education.
He discussed respect and compassion to workers and customers, race
relations, and respect and service to the environment. Unfortunately, this first book did not sell
well, and it was discontinued after its first printing.
But Dad continued
to pursue his dream. He went on to
author many successful books and teaching manuals, with his forte being manuals
employing the case study method. And he
imbued these books with his sense of ethics and fairness. And many years after his first book, he
finally had the opportunity to publish a book about business ethics. Dad’s academic writing was his major
contribution to the business world, as several of his books went through many
editions and were translated into many languages. And they provided a lucrative income for our
family. Even if he was not able to
affect business to the extent that he initially dreamed, he kept his dream
alive through his writing. One professor
who used Dad’s Marketing Mistakes and
Successes book through many editions over fifteen years wrote:
Attesting to Bob's almost magical
writing ability, it's about the only case book I've ever been able to get my
students to read! It's a unique book
that allowed his creativity and subtle humor to show through. I feel I've gotten to know him through the years
from the multiple editions of this book.
While many other academic authors seem to try to impress readers and
often write in an esoteric tone, I always found Bob's books to be written in a
straightforward and understandable way while still being rich with
insights. Over the years, many students
have commented on this. He truly will
be missed.
Dad
discusses in his memoir how as a child he dreamed of great athletic
exploits. For a skinny kid with a heart
murmur (he wrote) this was not a likely dream, but as an adult he found success
and satisfaction as a distance runner and local road race participant. And he also saw modest success and much joy
and satisfaction as a handicap golfer.
Dad began golfing as a young man, a pastime that I think he learned from
his father. He and my mother golfed
together before they married, and his success with writing enabled him to join
the Shaker Country Club, where my parents golfed for many years and my father
sometimes won club championships in the category of middling-handicapped
members. Dad taught my sister and me how
to golf, too. It was an activity that I
enjoyed very much – there is a satisfying feeling of ease and grace in hitting
a perfect golf shot. Unfortunately, such
moments are few and far between for many golfers, including myself. I would usually get at only one or two of
them in any round of golf I played. I
have not become a prolific golfer as an adult, and I occasionally feel some
regret about this, as I would like to have shared this more with my father, but
I think this is outweighed by the great success he had in instilling a running
tradition in to his family.
Dad’s
earliest successes (in school) came through writing, as did his greatest career
achievements as an adult. But his
earliest failure also came through writing.
No matter how many dog stories he wrote for his parents he never
convinced them to get a family dog. Some
of his last failures also came through writing.
After retiring from teaching, Dad sought to achieve his dream of writing
a best-selling novel that would touch the hearts of many. And while he completed three novels, he never
found a publisher and so never an audience for his novels. His crowning achievement as a writer, though,
may be the memoir that he completed in his 83rd year, shortly before
the stroke that would rob him of the ability to write any more. The memoir is, naturally, a treasure for my
sister and I, and I hope for the next generations of our family. But I think it is also a touching and
entertaining literary achievement that can be enjoyed by anyone. I have posted the memoir on-line and hope
that as many as possible will read and enjoy it.
Dad dreamed of things big and small to the end of his days. Even after his stroke, Dad continued to dream. Immediately after his stroke he was unable to drive, and he was incensed when he failed a driving competency test a few months after the stroke. And so he dreamed of driving again. He never did drive again, but the dream was not a failure because it motivated him to continue his rehab and to regain more of his speech and coordination than he likely would have otherwise.
And even
though he could not drive any more, he continued to have automotive dreams. He
had his mind set on buying a new car, perhaps another Lexus or other luxury
car. He never succeeded in this dream
either. Mom (and me) thought it an
unwise and unnecessary expense. But it
gave him something to look for, and we spent several pleasant afternoons
together visiting dealers and test driving cars. In the end, Dad felt contented with the fine
care that he had bought himself at his retirement.
And Dad
continued to have other dreams. Dreams
of another trip to Greenbrier Resort in West Virginia, and perhaps trips to
further places that he had never visited.
Dreams of more beers with his son, and of cookies from his wife. (Dad was an inveterate cookie monster.) Dreams of getting off his blood pressure and
blood thinner medicines. And dreams of
seeing more of the deer that increasingly populated the yards near our
home.
After his
stroke, Dad would sometimes have trouble finding the words to express himself.
Often he would find a suitable synonym, but sometimes not. Usually his family could understand what he
meant, even if his words were wrong. One
winter day he was unable to find the right word for a fawn laying in the snow
in the back yard. The word that came out
was carcass. And from then on he always used the word carcass when he meant deer. He would ask if I saw any carcasses in the
yard. We knew what he meant. And he surely loved those carcasses.
He wrote: “[D]reams do not have to
be of heroic proportions, but only of help and compassion toward others, of
guidance and inspiration for those who follow, with this perhaps done by
example.”
I believe that my father achieved these things through his
books, including his memoir, and most of all by the example of how he lived his
life.
Dad may not
have achieved all of his grand and small dreams in exactly the ways he first
envisioned, but in pursuit of his dreams he created a rich and successful
life. Dreams of athletic exploits turned
into a healthy 40-year lifestyle of healthy exercise and the creation of family
memories and traditions. Running no
doubt contributed to the excellent health he enjoyed until just before his
death. Pursuing his dream of
transforming the teaching of business led to a successful career with many
books translated into many languages, which have impacted business education in
modest ways, and also created a secure and comfortable environment for his
family to grow in.
At the end
of his memoir Dad wrote about his final dream: “I can only hope that the trace
I leave may be read by one who follows me, some empathic and compassionate
soul. But I’ll probably never know.” I know that he has - at least in the person
of me - and I hope in the hearts of others as well.
My father
gave so much to me through the years. A
comfortable and secure home full of love in which to grow. He was a positive
role model. And a writer of dreams. But the greatest gift from my dad – and his
greatest achievement - was also something touched upon by the priest at his
funeral mass. After remarking that he
had never heard my father speak, he also said that my father never missed a
Sunday mass. My father was always
there.
And so he
was for my mother, my sister, and me. My
parents had their 50th anniversary a month before he died, and their
marriage was a true loving partnership.
They shared running, golf, religion, and a commitment to health. They were physically together for most all of
the days in their 50 years together, and shared a lifestyle of commitment to
one another and their children. And they
supported each other throughout. For his
family, Dad was always there. For me, he
was always there.
And so
Dad’s spirit will always be alive in my heart.
Always.